MARK FLEMING
  • Home
  • About me
  • BrainBomb
  • Blog
  • Interviews
  • Articles
  • Music Therapy
  • My bands
    • 4 Minute Warning
    • Desperation A.M.
    • Little Big Dig
    • Axidents
    • Noniconic
  • Contact

it's a kind of a funny story: bittersweet comedy about a psychiatric unit

23/8/2020

0 Comments

 
Poster for 'It's a Kind of a Funny Story'
I caught 'It's a Kind of a Funny Story' on Netflix last night, a decent enough movie set in a psychiatric unit.

Starring Keir Gilchrist (Craig), Emma Roberts (Noelle), Zach Galifianakis (Bobby), it's an occasionally bittersweet comedy based on Ned Vizzini’s novel - 
recognised as a 2007 Best Book for Young Adults by the American Library Association.

The story opens with Craig contemplating jumping from Brooklyn Bridge, before checking himself into a psychiatric clinic. Because the teenage ward is undergoing renovations, he discovers his fellow patients are mostly adults – apart from Noelle, who has been self-harming.
The book got rave reviews, but although the film avoids a lot of psych ward cliches, the characters are mostly affectionate rather than disturbed. There are rarely moments of tension, and the only time staff have to react to an incident is when Bobby, having mucked up an interview for admission to a group home, starts tossing books from a shelf and has to be restrained.
Still from It's a Funny Kind of a Story
It's a Funny Kind of a Story, image from Den of Geek
There are amusing fantasy sequences. Craig reimagines singing ‘Under Pressure’ at a group music session in the bombastic style of Freddie Mercury, accompanied by patients in glam gear. 
Any movie whose central theme is raising awareness about mental health issues is worthy. Some critics complained that making a comedy set in a mental institution trivializes the subject. Locked wards and medicated patients are invariably the focus of drama, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest remaining the benchmark.

But in the context of a comedy as opposed to a ‘serious’ movie, it could be argued there’s a darkly humorous element about certain elements of the story. Craig starts his evening poised on a bridge parapet over traffic, only to fret about missing school in the morning because the clinic requires a mandatory one-week stay. Amongst the other patients is a Hassidic Jew who has fried his brain after dropping 100 acid tabs in one night, and complains about the least bit of noise. Another, a recluse, is only persuaded to prise himself out of his bedroom by hearing his native Egyptian music.

A Guardian review went so far as to describe the movie as ‘sickly, implausible and frankly questionable.’ Fair enough, except the screenplay is based on Ned Vizzini’s book – which is autobiographical. Vizzini was vocal about his struggles with severe depression, frequently writing and speaking about the subject. He took his own life in 2013, aged 32.


There are amusing cutaways, a familiar trope for movies based on teen books, and fantasy sequences. Craig reimagines singing ‘Under Pressure’ at a group music session in the bombastic style of Freddie Mercury, accompanied by patients in glam gear.

The end result is a feelgood movie based on mental health issues. Craig confides in the head physician, Dr Minerva, he wants to become an artist, admitting to being thankful his condition isn’t as bad as some of the other patients. In his voiceover at the conclusion, he appreciates his stay has helped him a lot, and he can look forward to getting through the rest of his life with the help of his family, friends and, of course, Noelle.
​
There’s also a fabulous soundtrack, including The Damned (‘Smash It Up’), Tom Robinson Band (‘2-4-6-8 Motorway’), Pharoah Sanders (‘Soledad’ – playing when Craig describes a wonderful memory to a therapist), Black Sabbath (the majestic ‘It’s Alright’) and a beautiful piano rendition of The Pixies’ ‘Where Is My Mind,’ by Maxence Cyrin.
0 Comments
    Picture
    MARK FLEMING
    ​EDINBURGH | SCOTLAND


    ​Categories

    All
    9/11
    Alan Brazil
    Amanda Prowse
    Amy Winehouse
    Andrew Mitchell
    Apples: Short Story
    Ari Up
    Armistice
    Arts Festival
    Ashdown
    Balconing
    Bankers
    Barack Obama
    Berlin Wall
    Bill Clinton
    Blackshirts
    Bobby Smith
    Book Censorship
    BrainBomb: Word Cloud
    Britains Got Talent
    Caroline Flack
    Chav: Sneering At The Underclass
    Child Cage Fight
    Citizens Advice
    Crash
    David Walliams
    Denise Johnson RIP
    Depression Awareness
    Desperation A.M.
    Dick Smith
    Disability
    DOK Exhibitions
    Domestic Violence
    Edinburgh Festival
    Faisal Shahzad
    Falklands War
    Finances
    Fortitude
    Frankie Abbbott
    Gary Speed
    Gerry Anderson
    Gettysburg
    Goodwin
    Gore Vidal
    Graham Crowden
    Ground Zero
    Guatemalan Stds
    Hacking Scandal
    Helga Etsby
    Hillary Clinton
    Hillsborough Justice
    Hiroshima 75th
    Homelessness
    Horrorshow
    Ian Curtis: 40 Years On
    Ibiza
    Ibrox Disaster
    Iraq
    It's A Kind Of A Funny Story
    Ivor Tiefenbrun
    Jake Bugg
    Jeremy Clarkson
    Jeremy Clarkson On PQ17
    Joe Strummer
    John Cormack
    John Hume RIP
    John Peel
    John Terry
    Keira Knightley
    Kelvin MacKenzie: Wants Police Apology
    Kristallnacht
    Leither Magazine
    Lemmy
    Llyr George
    Lying About Mental Health
    Malvinas V Falklands
    Marie Antoinettes
    Mental Health And Fat-shaming
    Mental Health Awareness Week 2018
    Mental Health During COVID-19
    Mental Health Prejudice
    Michael Portillo: Death Of A School Friend
    Middle East Peace Process
    Mosley
    National Rifle Association
    Neo Fascism
    News International
    Newtown Killings
    Nicolas Winding Refn
    Noel Edmunds
    One Love
    Organ Donation
    Ozark: Bipolar Disorder
    Paddy
    Penumbra
    Pete Shelley
    Picture House
    Poly Styrene
    Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
    Predator Drones
    Primal Scream
    Private Ellison
    Protestant Action 1930s
    Public Service Broadcasting: Lit Up
    Punishment Of Luxury
    Racism In Football
    Revenant
    Richard Ashcroft
    Rick Perry
    Robbie Hance
    Rupert Murdoch
    Samaritans
    Sarrazin
    Saughton Prison Visit
    Scars
    Scottish Tories
    Selfharm
    Sepp Blatter
    Sex And Violence
    Sex Pistols
    Shane Meadows
    Shaw Trust
    Silver Jubilee
    Simon Cowell
    Simon Weston
    Slaughter And The Dogs
    Smit
    Soldiers Suffering Breakdowns
    Stigma
    Stranglers Live Review
    Suicide
    Susan Boyle
    Syria - Crossing The Red Line
    Terry Jones
    The Clash
    The Damned
    The Slits
    The Sun - One-finger Salute To Lord Leveson
    The Wolf Warriors And Werewolves
    This Is England
    This Is England 86 Review
    Time To Change
    Tombstoning
    Tony Scott
    Tories
    Troy Davis
    Urban Noir Photo Exhibition
    U.S. Slavery Ends 1865
    Vic And Bob's Shooting Stars
    Wags
    Wayne Bridge
    Web Trolls
    World Alzheimer's Day
    World Suicide Prevention Day 2020
    X Factor
    X Ray Spex

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • About me
  • BrainBomb
  • Blog
  • Interviews
  • Articles
  • Music Therapy
  • My bands
    • 4 Minute Warning
    • Desperation A.M.
    • Little Big Dig
    • Axidents
    • Noniconic
  • Contact